Comments on: TIFF Review: Tony Manero

By: well

well — Tue, 21 Jul 2009 04:58:51 +0000

hate to say it, but, minus the stupid, i’d have to agree with the first critique.

are you compelled to say something when you have nothing to say?

the whole expression comes off as that of a self-important 20 something year old who thinks that because he or she wasn’t moved by a piece that required of him or her some awareness of the world -other than what he or she happens to know and like- that this is “news” in need of publishing.

By: John Allison

John Allison — Tue, 09 Sep 2008 23:44:09 +0000

Calling a review stupid is pretty lame. You are free to disagree with me about the movie and definitely feel free to explain why I am wrong with specifics but how this review sums up what I came away with from the movie. I did not find the relationships between the characters to be believable.

I can fully accept that part of the movie did not play well for me because I know very little about the culture of Chile also.

I stand by what I said and the more power to you to stand by how you feel about the movie. Every film will touch people differently. This one just didn’t touch me much at all.

By: Andy

Andy — Tue, 09 Sep 2008 18:00:50 +0000

John,
Sorry, don want to be aggressive…
But this is a very stupid review.
Is this serious?
Don’t think so. You Just want look cool.
If you didn’t get it, don’t let others fell afraid to see it.
You better learn before teaching.
This film has a strong and beautiful soul.
The beauty should also be in our eyes, not just in the films we see.
Best,
Andy