Say whatever you want about the usefulness or relevance of list-making, but let’s be honest, most of us make them and some of us, including me, make lists somewhat obsessively. Enter Flickchart, a movie-ranking website that’s been gathering buzz while in private beta over the past several months. Just last week (on 9/9/09, which was apparently a popular day for EVERYTHING to happen), Flickchart opened signups to the public, so you can go and register now without having an invite code from an existing user.
The basic idea behind Flickchart is that it’s sometimes difficult to create a list that’s really and truly the films you like the most – is Citizen Kane really your top film, or have you just been told it’s the best so often that you rank it there by default? And if you rate both Citizen Kane and, say, The Princess Bride five stars out of five, which one do you really like better? Developers Jeremy Thompson and Nathan Chase had difficulty believing some of the best lists they saw and decided to try a new approach: what if you had to choose between Citizen Kane and The Princess Bride right here and right now? That’s what Flickchart does. It places two films against each other (using a huge variety of worldwide posters, which makes the ranking process extra enjoyable) and asks you to pick which one you like better. If you want to rank everything by which you think is objectively better, I guess that’s your prerogative, but the general intent and the way it’s the most fun is to go with your gut “which of these films would I want to watch right now” reaction.
It takes a while to rank enough to get useful stats, but it’s pretty addicting. I’ve actually been in the beta phase for over a year, and I can’t tell you how many nights I’ve stayed up hours later than I intended going “oh, I’ll just do one more ranking…ooh, this is a good one, I’ll just do this one, too” and on and on. Once you’ve ranked a good number, you’ll start seeing your Top Twenty get more accurate, and you can filter down and view charts by genre, decade, year, and now even by star and director. Not finding enough variety while ranking, or not able to get your rankings accurate enough? Use the filters to rank, too, and delve into detailed genre breakdowns and years, or rank only your top twenty or fifty to get it perfect. Got that one film that ought to be in your top ten but it never comes up in random ranking? Go directly to the film’s page and rank it from there.
But it’s not much fun if you can only see it yourself, right? Well, you can also add your friends on Flickchart if they’re already there (start with me, if you want – I’m faithx5) and see how your rankings stack up against theirs. Nathan and Jeremy have recently added the ability share your top five films on Facebook, or share individual pairings on Facebook or FriendFeed to generate discussion – and help you decide if you’re on the fence! A lot of great FriendFeed discussions have resulted from this, and I hope that Facebook sharing (which is newer) has a similar effect. Flickchart also has a built-in Twitter client on the side, so you can see who’s discussing Flickchart and add your own thoughts. In addition to all that, if you’d rather keep it all on-site, you can discuss matchups directly on Flickchart and take a look at detailed stats of how often films win their matchups and where each film ranks among all Flickchart users as well as yourself.
Flickchart may not be the end-all and be-all of movie ranking systems – certainly it gears far more toward the individual and subjective gut instincts than the considered and objective. In that sense, it’s better to think of it as a way to generate “favorite” lists rather than “best” lists, but there’s not anything particularly wrong with that. It’s kind of a welcome relief from the “these are the greatest films of the year/all time/1950s sci-fi with zombies” lists that we end up making all the time. Often, these subjective lists are much more interesting and revealing. And building them with Flickchart is just a helluvalot of fun.
So what’s next for Nathan and Jeremy? Well, first off, something I’ve been asking them about for a long time: A user-submission system to help finish building their database. I mentioned I’ve been using Flickchart for months, and Nathan’s been after me to feature it on RowThree for nearly as long. My deal was that they mostly had popular, newer, American films in the database and that as much as I enjoyed using Flickchart, I didn’t feel like it could be pushed as a competent rating system, at least not for our cinephile-leaning readership, until it had some basic classics like, oh, Bonnie & Clyde, The Seven Samurai, The Wizard of Oz, The 400 Blows, among others. All of these titles and many more have been added in the last few updates, and the one that finally pushed me over, my beloved Band of Outsiders, showed up just before the public launch last week. So I had no more excuses. But there are still a lot of films to add, especially foreign ones, and obviously more every year, so a way for users to expand the database is becoming increasingly important. This should be implemented soon, and will allow users to submit information and correct existing entries. New information will still be verified, but the process will be highly expedited.
And Nathan and Jeremy aren’t stopping with movies – they’re planning on making similar sites for music, television, books, video games, etc. Music is first on the agenda, and I can’t wait to start ranking up Rilo Kiley on there. I’m curious to see how they’re going to do music. Nathan tells me ranking by album and artist will probably be first. I think ranking by song would be insane, though! In any case, I’ll be banging on the doors of that beta as well. Because goodness knows I don’t already have enough addictive things demanding my time. And thankfully, Nathan promises that “we certainly won’t leave Flickchart to lie as we branch out – we’ve got a laundry list of ideas for ways to add and improve Flickchart much further than it exists today.” I’m excited to see what else they have in store, after adding so many features in the past few months. Keep up with them on FriendFeed and Twitter.
Ooh, and I almost forgot to mention – away from your computer and bored? Type in iphone.flickchart.com to get a mobile-friendly version of the site. It doesn’t have all the filtering and sharing features, but it’s gotten me through many a boring meeting. (I haven’t tested it on non-iPhone mobiles, but it looks as though it would work on phones with touch screens, at least.) And now you’ll have to excuse me – I have some more movies to rank.