26 Comments


  1. Rick Vance says:

    I was wondering when you guys would go for the documentary homework. Also surprised Andrew hasn’t pulled one about costume/set design yet.

  2. Nat Almirall says:

    I believe that in the spreadsheet that you gave Courtney my A+. And Kurt, you need to see The Late Show stat.

  3. Andrew James says:

    For homework, everyone gets an “A” except Dick who gets an “A+” for just happening to mention a film I saw during the film festival this week.

  4. rot says:

    Even though I would agree the film gives away a bunch of the story in the first ten minutes, to really get the best experience of The Imposter, I would recommend skipping over Kurt’s mention of it on this Cinecast. All you need to know is it is awesome, it is a cinematic documentary, it is about a missing child and by the title alone there is something to do with an imposter.

    It is like Kurt says, a highly manipulative movie in the best way, and while it does have a lot of Morris/Marsh in its cinematic ambitions, as a piece of manipulation and just as a true story that gets stranger it feels, to me, a lot like Dear Zachary. I was talking with James McNally leaving the film and I know he was not a fan of Dear Zachary but a big fan of The Imposter, and his main criticism with Dear Zachary was just how manipulative it was. To me these films are both working from the same handbook, and both push into some potentially uncomfortable questions about how the filmmakers used people, and withheld plot points, in the process of telling their stories. I love both Dear Zachary and The Imposter and do not feel any kind of ill-feelings towards how the stories are told or how the people are treated.

  5. I’d like to thank Cinecast for being a great way for me to spend my downtime at Hot Docs yesterday. :)

    Here’s my current top 3 at midway point of the festival:
    1) Her Master’s Voice
    2) The Imposter
    3) Beauty is Embarrassing

    It’s a very interesting one for me tonight (plan on seeing the James Franco doc)

    • Kurt Halfyard says:

      I’ll be at the midnight screening for Francophrenia tonite too.

    • CS says:

      The Imposter is the best film I have seen at Hot Docs so far. I have watched the film twice now and I absolute agree with everything Kurt stated in the show. I think this film will be studied by documentary students/filmmakers for years to come. The thing I noticed the most on the second viewing is how wonderful the editing is in the film. Especially the subtle way the film cuts between the taking heads and the re-enactments based on simple body gestures.

      As for the other films Kurt mentioned:

      Beauty is Embarrassing – pure joy. I love the whole message of embracing whatever your passion is.

      Despite the Gods – A solid film that made me eager to seek out Hisss.

      The Mechanical Bride – I liked the film but I think it would have worked better as a three part television series. The film tries to shove in way too much stuff.

      Tchoupitoulas – Once I got beyond the blatant manipulation, which took a while, I was able to appreciate the film on the level the directors’ intended. It is quite a unique experience. Still, I wish the manipulative aspects were not so obvious.

      My top three so far:
      1. The Imposter
      2. The Invisible War
      3. (tie) Beware of Mr. Baker/ Beauty is Embarrassing

  6. I was thinking about Kurt’s statements about the changes in music in the Donnie Darko director’s cut.

    It’s really not all that different:
    - Killing Moon switched for Never Tear Us Apart (most obvious change)
    - Killing Moon goes back to original location during the party scene, replacing Under the Milkyway Tonight
    - Under the Milkyway Tonight moved to Car Conversation
    - Stay by Oingo Boingo is added to the scene where Donnie’s sister announces she was accepted into college.

    That’s it. Everything else is exactly the same as in the theatrical cut.

    I actually like the director’s cut, though I would still recommend the theatrical cut for first viewings.

    • Oh and the score was changed slightly (different pieces in different scenes)

      • Kurt says:

        They swap out Notorious in the SparkleMotion Dance sequence for Petshop boys West End Girls, if I recall…

        • Kurt says:

          Maybe that was only in my addled brain. I think that Kelly intended to use that song and never followed through with it…even in the Director’s Cut. My confusion.

          Add it to the growing errors in this particular 8am Cinecast.

    • It’s hard to believe that I first saw the film 10 years ago this summer. I plan on both writing a retrospective blog post (since the film actually kicked off my desire to get into film studies) and upgrading the film to blu-ray.

  7. NARBY says:

    CORRECTION: Guy Pierces Carl Winslow/Reginald Vel Johnson esqu contact in Lockout is not the same actor who played the projectionist in Inglorious Basterds, It’s Lennie James. A character actor who has appeared in the TV series Jericho, The Walking Dead, etc.

  8. Goon says:

    Neither Kurt nor Andrew were aware that Frank in God Bless America is Joel Murray, Bill Murray, John and Brian Doyle’s other brother?

    • Andrew James says:

      Bobcat did actually mention that in his intro to the film. I just forgot. It makes sense now that he reminds me so much of the Caddy Master in Caddyshack. Who is also Bill Murray’s brother.

      I love it when a plan comes together.

Leave a comment