Review: Cars 2

Directors: John Lasseter, Brad Lewis (Toy Story, A Bug’s Life, Cars)
Story: John Lasseter, Brad Lewis, Dan Fogelman
Screenplay: Ben Queen
Producer: Denise Ream
Starring: Owen Wilson, Larry the Cable Guy, Michael Caine, Emily Mortimer, Eddie Izzard, John Turturro
MPAA Rating: G
Running time: 112 min

Though filled with their typical beautiful animation and penchant for including a myriad of little touches and background jokes, Pixar’s 2011 summer entry Cars 2 is easily their least significant piece of work. It’s not as horrible as many people expected (and even seemed to want it to be), but it doesn’t feel like the same effort has gone into the story and characters as even their lesser films. There’s a great deal of creativity here (in the details – particularly when they take their car society to other parts of the world), but not as much artistry. For the most part it’s flash and brash and gets bogged down with chase after chase after chase. The story isn’t propelled by the characters this time around – and everything suffers as a result. There’s some fun to be had, but not really a great deal of humour and not a speck of warmth.

The majority of the film is based around a conspiracy to ensure alternative fuel sources are ridiculed, oil and gas remain as the primary source of energy and that cars that were regarded as “lemons” (Gremlins, Yugos, etc.) get more respect. Through a World Grand Prix sponsored by the discoverer of a brand new clean source of fuel, Lightning McQueen and, primarily, his rusty sidekick Tow Mater become wrapped up in spy hijinks to prove that the conspiracy exists. This all provides the backdrop and impetus for a multitude of car chases topped by a barrage of weaponry. As mentioned, Larry The Cable Guy’s voice takes centre stage when Tow Mater accidentally and unwittingly becomes involved in the spy efforts to bust open the criminal activities. As two agents try to fit the pieces together (voiced by Michael Caine and Emily Mortimer), they believe Mater to be their American contact. While they bounce through different corners of the globe meeting up with the 3 races of the World Grand Prix (in Japan, Italy and England), the spies close in on the cartel of dud cars who plan to control the world’s gas supply and embarrass the top race cars while they’re at it. Mater gets the lion’s share of the action while Lightning McQueen simply battles an Italian F1 car and considers what his friendship to Mater really means to him. The rest of the “Gang” from Radiator Springs are shuffled to the sidelines and are only occasionally glimpsed throughout the movie.

Therefore, your mileage will depend heavily on how much Larry The Cable Guy you can take in one sitting (when things aren’t blowing up that is). Speaking as someone who actually enjoyed the first film and has no major issues with Larry as a voice actor or even as a stand-up comedian, Mater wears thin as a compelling character pretty quickly. The plot gets moved forward by Mater continually doing something stupid or naive and even though he always shows he has a good heart (or should I say pistons?), there’s little arc available for any of these characters. Short of a minor fight between McQueen and Mater, there’s little to resolve for the denizens of Radiator Springs and so it’s all up to the machinations of the spy plot to keep your interest. Each chase is clearly designed with great care and there’s always something inventive going on, but there’s simply nothing to latch onto except for spotting the details (the references to previous movies, character names, the kaleidoscope of colours, etc.). I smiled and chuckled occasionally, but not once did I laugh out loud. And, more importantly, neither did the two 10 year-olds I brought to the screening. Even after the film, neither of them spoke a single word about it – when asked, they said they liked it but did not proffer up any examples of why or relive any of the moments.

I can’t quite get to the point of accusing Pixar and Disney of being completely cynical by making an hour and fifty minute long toy commercial, but it probably wouldn’t take a great deal or persuading since there is a definite lack of effort to build something original this time around. Lasseter obviously likes these creations and still has his boyish sense of fun, but he’s lost (at least this time out) his adult radar for character-based humour that pulls you in and provides the deeper pleasure. Or perhaps just blinded by the shiny lure of residuals from the sales of little Tow Maters. Ka-ching!


Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Kurt Halfyard
Admin

Doesn’t it say something right there in the poster: Cars 2 ‘from the creator of Toy Story 3’? Why not just write ‘from the creators of Toy Story’? Surely they do not have to be condescending enough to believe that people will only remember the last movie? Or are they emphasizing that Pixar is now in the sequel/franchise game? Not sure.

Andrew James
Admin

Bob, you pretty much nailed it. The film isn’t as terrible as it looked like it was going to be, but it wasn’t good either. It looked f’ing fantastic and had some gags that were amusing. This is clearly their most lackluster performance.

I really did dig the opening sequence that played like the opening of a classic James Bond film. I felt like maybe the movie wanted to go in that direction but had to placate the kids with more Larry the Cable Guy.

If the movie had stuck to this…

… as it did in that opening sequence, I would’ve been a lot happier.

Though like you said, picking out the details in the scenery and cross-culture is part of the fun. Though to be fair, that was a big chunk of what is great about the first movie. It felt a little rehashed here.

Andrew James
Admin

And how about that opening short? Talk about phoning it in! Sure it was amusing and impressive that they got everyone back, but ANOTHER Toy Story!!?

Come the fuck on!

That said, Michael Keaton still kicks ass.

Kurt Halfyard
Admin

I don’t have an issue with the Toy Story 3b short, it’s kind of like the epilogue focusing on the toys rather than the kids. Like an after the credits sequence that they pushed to the next film for the heck of it.

Andrew James
Admin

After great animations like the creative clouds or the magic rabbit or especially Night and Day, TS4 was insulting and LAZY!

Disney meeting:
“Hey guys, got any good ideas for an awesome short to screen before Cars 2?”
“Yeah! Let’s get a bunch of characters we’ve already done three times and see what they’re up to.”
“Seems kind of unnecessary don’t you think?”
“No it will be great. The kids will love seeing Spanish Buzz Lightyear say ‘cat poop.'”
“Alright, let’s do it!”

Lame.

Kurt Halfyard
Admin
Andrew James
Admin

Well, it’s a official. Pixar has jumped the shark. It had to happen some day.

Cars 2
Monsters, Inc. 2
Toy Story 4

Kurt Halfyard
Admin

Two Words: “SHAREHOLDER VALUE” – thus Pixar’s annexation into Disney is now complete. They didn’t bring Disney Up, the Mouse House brought Pixar Down. (not in terms of lucre, but in terms of their initial burst of creative juices giving way to a need to feed the bottom line.)

Jonathan
Admin

I refuse to believe the Toy Story 4 snippet until Pixar confirms it. YOU LIE, TOM HANKS!

rot
Guest

let it be a prequel or reboot.

Kurt Halfyard
Admin

Wouldn’t it have been daring if PIXAR had made a Cars 2 story in the world with totally difference characters (which is what that above poster suggests) … instead of dragging the Radiator Springs folks into an adventure that is a total 180 in tone/theme/sentiment from the original? (i.e. the value of a quiet life and slowing down / country living)

This is probably why I spend so much time defending 28 Weeks Later… because the film keeps the world, but gives a new perspective with new characters.

(See also Romero’s Dead Trilogy, and why a lot of folks love Halloween III)

Ms Curious
Guest

This is a film that couldn’t quite make up its mind. Adults or kids? Tried hard to run between the two and didn’t quite make it for me (the adult)!