
Welcome to the big list post for 2009! As it takes a while to get the Row Three wheel a turnin’ for something involving nearly all the contributors in these parts, we are a little bit late to the list game (that was strange to type, considering it is only January 8th, but such is the way of online list-making), and even then some releases were not seen by many of us (from Crazy Heart to The Lovely Bones, both of which are 2010 releases in Canada), but we decided to plant the flag in the ground anyway. Judging from the pleasing variety of films considered below, it was a varied year, with very few consensus titles and those (A Serious Man, Fantastic Mr. Fox and Inglourious Basterds for instance) from reliable auteur filmmakers playing to their strengths. Intense and sophisticated childrens films (Fantastic Mr. Fox, Up, Coraline, Where The Wild Things Are), intelligent science fiction (Moon, District 9, Mr. Nobody) and films about people coping in hard financial times (The Girlfriend Experience, Up In The Air, Precious, Collapse) are but a few of the themes to emerge in hindsight. We hope you enjoyed past year as much as we did (we celebrated Row Three’s second birthday – with no fanfare – in November) and here is hoping that 2010 holds forth the same sort of variety and daring in the multiplex (District 9, The Hurt Locker, Where The Wild Things Are) and in the arthouse (Enter The Void, The White Ribbon, Antichrist).
Criteria:
Each writer had his/her own criteria for putting this list together. Aside from a couple of festival screenings, most of these titles were released in one form or another (From wide release to direct to DVD and video-on-demand) in North America at some point in the calendar year 2009.
UPDATE: If you are using Internet Explorer as your browser, please be sure it is the latest version (version 7) or some other much better browser (like Chrome or Firefox) to view the lists. Otherwise they may not appear correctly. Thanks!
Onward…
![]() |
![]() |
|
10) Star Trek / Push / Knowing The sci-fi triple threat. Though not exactly mastperpieces, I can’t help but admire each of these films for what they accomplished. Star Trek successfully breathed new life into a dying franchise; Push came and went with little fanfare but this unlikely super hero story has a grittiness to it that is missing from most major blockbusters; and Ebert knows what’s up. Knowing may have its problems but there’s a lot to love in Alex Proyas’ newest offering. It may not be Dark City but it’s in the ballpark. 9) Cole 8 ) Fish Tank 7) The Girl 6) The White Ribbon 5) Downloading Nancy 4) The Hurt Locker 3) Polytechnique 2) Two Lovers 1) Redland - – honorable mentions: Inglourious Basterds, District 9, The Box, Moon, In the Loop, I Killed My Mother |
10) Avatar Yes it has a simple story that has been told before but 99% of the movies put out suffer from this. I found the character compelling and I cared about what happened. You add that to a beautiful looking movie you have something special. If this had not been called a game changer I believe more people would be less critical of it. 9) Watchmen 8 ) Bronson 7) New York Lately 6) 9 5) Red Cliff 4) The Hurt Locker 3) Drag Me to Hell 2) Inglorious Basterds 1) Ink - – honorable mentions: Black Dynamite, Moon, Ponyo, Zombieland, Fantastic Mr. Fox, A Serious Man, Rough Cut |
![]() |
![]() |
|
10) Up It’s not the best Pixar film by any stretch, but when it works it’s a moving and entertaining adventure that still impresses. The opening 15 minutes are incredible, reducing many to tears before the film had really got started. The rest of the film struggles to recapture this and turns a bit silly at times, but it’s still better than most. 9) Vampire Girl Vs Frankenstein Girl 8 ) Paranormal Activity 7) Where the Wild Things Are 6) District 9 5) Lake Mungo 4) Avatar 3) A Serious Man 2) In The Loop 1) The Wrestler - – honorable mentions: The Disappeared, The House of the Devil, Star Trek, Zombieland, The Forbidden Door (AKA Pintu Terlarang) |
10) (500) Days of Summer Finally someone makes a solid romantic comedy told from the male point of view without devolving into Apatow-esque immaturity. From JGL’s winning performance to spontaneous musical numbers, I was delighted from start to finish. 9) Up 8 ) Broken Embraces 7) Fish Tank 6) Where the Wild Things Are 5) An Education 4) A Serious Man 3) Up in the Air 2) I Killed My Mother 1) Inglourious Basterds - – honorable mentions: Black Dynamite, Sin Nombre, The Fantastic Mr. Fox, The Loved Ones, Moon, In the Attic, The Girlfriend Experience, Guy and Madeline on a Park Bench, Drag Me to Hell |
![]() |
|
|
10) The Limits of Control Jim Jarmusch’s deliberate ode to architecture, form and patient viewing is bumped into masterpiece territory by the wonderful cinematography of Christopher Doyle and the handsome (dude can WEAR a suit) figure of Isaach De Bankolé. 9) Mr. Nobody 8 ) The Hurt Locker 7) The White Ribbon 6) Up In The Air 5) Fantastic Mr. Fox 4) A Serious Man 3) Mammoth 2) Inglourious Basterds 1) Enter The Void - – so many honorable mentions (any of these could be #11): Where The Wild Things Are, Antichrist, Symbol, In The Loop. Agora, Deliver Us From Evil, The Road, Moon, Collapse, The Informant!, Drag Me To Hell, The Class, House of the Devil, Soul Kitchen, The Sky Crawlers (viewed in 2008 released in 2009), Tokyo Sonata (viewed in 2008, Released in 2009) Ponypool (viewed in 2008, released in 2009), Vinyan (viewed in 2008, released in 2009), Splice, My Dog Tulip, Summer Hours (viewed in 2008 released in 2009), Public Enemies, An Education, The Girlfriend Experience, Black Dynamite, District 9, Visage, Grace, Three Monkeys, Valhalla Rising, Stingray Sam, The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus - – Wish I would have seen:Love Exposure, Funny People, Mary and Max |
10) A Serious Man Yet another top tier film from The Coens; adding one more notch in their ever expanding belt of fantastic cinematic yarns. Retreating to their childhood, Joel and Ethan have put together a story based on hypothesis, superstition, karma and religion all tangled within everyday suburban life of the 1950′s. With tragically fantastic performances, it’s just one more piece of evidence proving The Coens are the greatest story tellers of our generation. 9) Up 8 ) New York Lately 7) Fantastic Mr. Fox 6) The Class 5) Antichrist 3) TIE: Inglorious Basterds 3) TIE: Broken Embraces 2) The Girlfriend Experience 1) Where the Wild Things Are - – honorable mentions: *Mr. Nobody, Anvil! The Story of Anvil, An Education, Drag Me to Hell, Surveillance, New York I Love You, It Might Get Loud, Ink, The White Ribbon |
![]() |
![]() |
|
10) Freeter’s Distress 9) Up 8 ) Star Trek 7) (500) Days of Summer 6) Up in the Air 5) Visage 4) Micmacs à tire-larigot 3) A Serious Man 2) The Hurt Locker 1) Inglourious Basterds - – honorable mentions: Aruongaku, Adventureland |
10) The Loved Ones 9) Fantastic Mr. Fox 8 ) Adventureland 7) Love At The Twilight Motel 6) Micmacs 5) Soul Kitchen 4) L’Enfer D’Henri-Georges Clouzot 3) Best Worst Movie 2) Up 1) Black Dynamite - – honorable mentions: Castaway On The Moon, Ashes Of American Flags, Iron Maiden: Flight 666, Grace, I Love You, Man, Air Doll, The Headless Woman, Black, Perrier’s Bounty, Inglourious Basterds, The Misfortunates, Five Hours From Paris, (500) Days Of Summer, The Cove, Away We Go, Funny People, Star Trek, The Box. |
![]() |
![]() Add this all up and you got some bad-ass perpetrators and they’re here to stay… |
|
- Without a doubt the best year of film, period. My honorable mentions would make a solid parallel top ten for any other year. 10) The Fantastic Mr. Fox 9) Funny People 8 ) Rip! A Remix Manifesto 7) A Single Man 6) Dear Zachary 5) Wendy and Lucy 4) The Limits of Control 3) Away We Go 2) Mammoth 1) Collapse - – honorable mentions: The Cove, The White Ribbon, AntiChrist, Star Trek, Gran Torino, We Live in Public, The Hurt Locker, Hunger (saw 2008), Inglourious Basterds, Where the Wild Things Are |
10) Broken Embraces 9) Micmacs 8 ) Fantastic Mr. Fox 7) Up 6) Mammoth 5) Up in the Air 4) Where the Wild Things Are 3) The Hurt Locker 2) A Serious Man 1) Inglourious Basterds Discuss. - – honorable mentions: Adventureland, Drag Me to Hell, Moon, Star Trek, In the Loop. |






















I love the Consensus (kinda)… the top five I don’t even have on my list.
Push! Nice!
Top marks to Kurt and Andrew for being awesome with their #1s.
Why does it not surprise me that only one of my picks made the top 10 consensus list?
Six of mine did. Either I win, or I have the boringest taste in the world. Yeah, I’m going with the latter.
why do people not like the Road more? Is it just because the book is so strong in people’s mind.
It stayed with me for days and is among the top echelon of my favorites this year.
I didn’t love The Road. I liked it a lot. But not sure if it’s the book that hits me so much harder or if it’s because I saw Last Ride later in the week and though similar, thought it was a much better movie.
Oh, but Marina, you watched and loved Fish Tank! Yay!
I loved the Road when I saw it at TIFF, but I didn’t like it as much the second time… still a solid film though but seriously this has been an insanely good year for film that it just didn’t make it for me.
“I loved the Road when I saw it at TIFF, but I didn’t like it as much the second time… “
Isn’t this the exact OPPOSITE of your argument yesterday? I thought the movie should be judged on your experience that one time. wft.
I now think of you as Middle-Of-The-Road Jandy
@Rusty, “why do people not like the Road more? Is it just because the book is so strong in people’s mind.”
Yep. The film is fantastic. It is really good, but sadly nowhere near the book. A simple case of trying to adapt perfection into a different medium. I think Hillcoat and co. have made a significant achievement with the film, but it will always suffer in comparison to the book. And that divide colours where the film ends up as peoples favourites.
Entries 9 and 10 on that list are kind of baffling (or indicative of the varied year) They barely feel ‘consensus’ and could easily be replaced with THE WHITE RIBBON and THE LIMITS OF CONTROL.
How did Broken Embraces get on there, and who was it that did the consensus again…hmmm….
I have the math of the entry tabulation if you guys wanna take a look.
Broken Embraces = 3 pts from Jandy, 8 pts from Andrew = 11 pts total, 2 lists
Limits of Control = 1 pt from Kurt, 7 from Rot = 8 pts total, 2 lists
The White Ribbon = 4pts from Kurt, 5 pts from Marina = 9 pts, 2 lists.
Broken Embraces wins.
@Andrew
No I said it doesn’t REQUIRE a second viewing to be judged, but in this case I did actually see the film twice and so the accumulative effect has to be acknowledged (I can’t NOT be the person who saw the film twice and have my present opinion of the film remain fixed in the past).
I am privileging the (relative) present at all times, and not thinking about what The Road will mean to me ten years from now and than grading the experience on that.
So its kind of arbitrary then? I agree it doesn’t require a second viewing. But you’ve just acknowledged that a movie that just gets better every time you watch it can be more valuable than a movie you saw once, liked it, but are afraid to watch again because it might not live up to your memories. Likewise, a film that doesn’t hold up on future viewings (The Road) can be construed as inferior.
Consensus might not be the right term…OK, it’s definitely not the right term (the top 6 weren’t on my list).
Still makes for an interesting 10 though – some obvious picks along with a few surprises. I expect there was also some rolling up of honourable mentions.
you mean there is no hierarchal value to individual lists? Don’t Kurt and I trump you and Jandy
arbitrary? well our tastes change as we change, if you mean not static, then absolutely. The difference is I am not predicting what the future will hold for the film and adding that to the value, I am taking stock of it right now. We are almost treading into Hurley time travel conversation here, but the present is not a fixed point, its wherever you are at when you think of it.
So at least you agree that subsequent viewings of a movie can affect its position on a person’s list over time (and if that experience grows, the film’s status should as well).
I agree with you that pretending to know how you’ll feel about a movie in 10 years maybe isn’t the best way to critique a film. But with something like Fantastic Mr. Fox, I think an argument can be made that it is timeless. And for me, that word is a positive thing for a film and not a negative. Therefore, just one more piece of data (weighed however much stock one wants to put into something like that) to include when deciding where it should go on one’s list.
The “consensus” lists never really work out unless we all sat around a table for 10 hours arguing each and every movie over. Filmjunk did theirs for the decade and their picks had to be on everyone’s list. This has its pluses but also negatives. Perhaps we could have said that movies had to be on at least 3 lists or perhaps 4.
Oh and I trump everyone cause I totally destroy the site with my mad coding skills…. not that I would although maybe next year the consensus list should look a lot more like mine.
I agree, but focus on what it makes you feel now rather than what it may or may not make you feel later seems like a pretty logical approach. and if you have only seen a film once and you think it has no rewatch value that to me doesn’t necessary make it a lesser film, or even affect how I think of the film.
I can do that too, John. :p How about this: if next year’s list isn’t a perfect composite of our two lists, we turn the site into a circa 1997 GeoCities site clone?
Mike, I agree on not trying to project ten years into the future and guess what I’ll think. It’s a fun thought experiment, but it doesn’t really enter into my valuation. I’ve used that timespan a time or two in recent comments not because I’m projecting my critique that far into the future, but because it’s a nice round number and I know that the films I loved (and hated) ten years ago aren’t the ones I love and hate now. Ten years is a good time span for revaluation.
As far as focusing on what you feel now…what I feel right when I walk out of a film is often just as dependent on whether the sun’s shining when I leave the theatre or if it’s raining or if I spent the last five minutes dying to go the bathroom or if there was a group of annoying teenagers near me. My attempts to think through a film over the next weeks are attempts to mitigate those biases.
I managed to catch Fish Tank on Tuesday (I posted a comment on Jandy’s review) and it was too late for this list, but I would have put it in at number 6, pushing Up out of my list.
Awesome consensus list! I wonder were Children of Men exists in this list extravaganza, and although on the cusp (2000) Almost Famous?
And did anyone note that GLORIOUS BANNER!!!!
It’s weird. Children of Men only appears on two lists. Mine and Jonathan. Both of us have it right around #50. Funny, I think that’s a film that deserves more scrutiny and probably a much higher spot than it got. Not sure what the problem is there. Especially after listening to Sean talk about it on the FJ podcast (as their #2 of the decade).
Oh, and thanks on the banner. I was going to put up a link o the hi-res version if anyone wants more detail. I’ll try to remember to do that over the weekend.
That banner is VERY sweet.
On THE ROAD, I too enjoyed it quite a bit but not enough to put it on my list. And I don’t have the book to blame because I didn’t care for it all that much either.
And I didn’t mean anything by the fact that only one of the films on my list made the consensus list. It’s just funny that a similar thing happened last year. It always surprises me that as much as we may agree throughout the year, when it comes down to our favourites – we’re all very different.
My favorite thing about the banner above is the almost hidden nod to Antichrist but actually takes up about 3/4 of the entire image.
Oh, and the slight reflection added to the bottom of Sam Rockwell’s feet.
Props to Andrew for having the best list…or at least the one most similar to my own.
Dear John,
How do you “have no interest in the Black Freighter”? It’s a part of the story just the same as the rest of it. Plus, it’s pretty shweet. Watch the director’s cut with the black freighter interwoven. It’s well done, I do think.
While I still have plenty to watch this year (Fisk Tank, Precious, Crazy Heart, A Single Man, The Hurt Locker, The Girlfriend Experience), here is my tentative top ten of 2009:
10. Funny People
9. An Education
8. Where the Wild Things Are
7. The Road
6. Ink
5. A Serious Man
4. Moon
3. (500) Days of Summer
2. Up in the Air
1. Inglourious Basterds
My top five, I feel very, very strongly about. The others, I could see getting bumped off or reshuffled when I watch what I have remaining to watch.
Great list, Jonathan! I just watched Inglourious Basterds again tonight, and it’s still just as amazing as it was the first time. Every scene I kept going “oh, this part is AWESOME.”
Agreed that as a film, the showy confidence of Inglourious Basterds (as in “oooh, this part is Awesome!”) is pretty infectious.
It certainly isn’t a life changing movie, but it’s a movie I’m going to watch twenty years from now and still have a hell of a time. The first time I heard “bonjourno” in the theater… I’m not sure if I have ever laughed that hard during a movie.
Just noticed Kurt dropped in Mary and Max in his “wish I would’ve seen” list above. I can say that movie is certainly an underseen gem. Possibly the best animated film of 2009 – certainly better than Pixar’s Up after re-watching that.