• TIFF 09 Review: Kamui

    kamuimoviestill

    A ninja epic without a story, Yoichi Sai’s adaptation of the 40 year old manga source material limps onto screen with hollow characters, bad CGI and way, way too much run-time. For enthusiasts of mythology of the ninja there is something on offer, and its ambitious attempt at an unfocused narrative (for those who make it to the end of the film this spelled out as obvious as it can be) is intriguing on paper, but actual execution – particularly in the pacing department – is sorely lacking (even by Japanese fantasy epic standards; Gojoe, Casshern I am looking at you).

    Outcast from his vile and villainous ninja clan, despite being potentially the most talented of the next generation, Kamui ends up walking the earth alone and hunted at a very young age. He unwittingly joins forces with boisterous and amusing Hanbei (the only character in the movie with any spark in him) after Hanbei kills the horse of a local (evil) lord. Ending up in Habei’s anonymous fishing village and essentially moving in with the fisherman’s family, Kamui attempts to find a life there, but his past keeps creeping back up, endangering his chances at peace and family.


    The attraction here is the wide colour saturated oceanic vistas and big set pieces. It is ironic in a big action epic that the quiet moments of fishing life are the more compelling ones, mainly in the picture perfect sea-side village an idyllic fishing voyages. Even if they are on the cliché side and seem completely at odds with the films ominous and voluminous prologue, Hanbei’s family life and its attraction to a lone warrior as a viable option is interesting enough. But the little dramas that function as the films plot are sparse and unfinished. The pirates who hunt sharks are a welcome distraction if you can get past the horrible computer renders of their ship and their ‘mega-shark’ prey. Of course the picture ends up in a huge CGI battle with the ninja clan that has little weight or significance. And the film seems to be saying that as long as the ninja make art of their prowess for violence, they are valuable to Japan. The function and value of art is a pretty high minded premise for a simple, populist action-melodrama and the fun disposable family entertainment tone is awkwardly abutted with violence against children. A bleak, ambiguous finale is more baffling than it is challenging or interesting. The collection of underwater, tree-top and sea-side ninja battles are not enough to enliven the whole turgid affair. If only all the elements were better conceived, we might have something. As it stands, Shinobi offers a more compelling scenario and characters and that is not saying much.

    Tags: , , , ,

3 Comments


  1. Bob Turnbull says:

    Man, people sure get down on “Shinobi”…It’s goofy, but I liked it.

    I just posted my own review of “Kamui” and felt pretty similar to you. I liked it better, but I think there was too much reverence to the idea of the manga (I haven’t read it, but that’s just a feeling I get). The manga apparently has numerous additional volumes, so it looks like the story is left open to accommodate sequels.

    As for the mega-sharks, they made me think of this scene from “Shark Attack 3: Megalodon”. Not as gloriously stupid, but it’s the first thing that came to mind. And yes, it’s sad that I know this scene in the first place…

  2. Andrew James says:

    I really didn’t enjoy Kamui much at all. Not that I was expecting much but this was pretty low quality stuff. Effects aren’t everything but when your film starts with an “epic” battle in the woods and looks like crap, it starts the movie off right away with a bad taste in your mouth.

    Agreeing with Kurt, the most compelling moments in the film are the quiet down times at the fishing village. The fighting is boring, pointless and repetitive.

    I did really like the ultra-BLUE of the ocean. That looked neat.

    PS – Kurt, love this keyboard.

  3. Kurt says:

    Ha. Off topic, but Andrew, the keyboard alone is why you should switch to mac. I have a mac keyboard on my PC even. They are swell.

Leave a comment