Has there ever been a good SNL movie?

posted by Jonathan B.

the sex symbol.

08
Jul
2009

Well, yeah. A couple. Who doesn’t love The Blues Brothers? Or the first Wayne’s World? Since those two, most have been poor to downright awful, which is probably why there hasn’t been a movie based on an SNL character since 2000’s The Ladies Man – that is, until now, with the announcement that there is going to be a MacGruber movie, the SNL character that spoofs – you can probably guess it – MacGyver.

Directed by Jorma Taccone of Lonely Island fame and starring Will Forte as MacGruber, apparently Val Kilmer and Ryan Phillippe are also in talks to co-star, according to the Hollywood Reporter. The movie’s premise:

The legendary, much decorated MacGruber is pulled out of retirement as a monk in Ecuador by a colonel, who needs him once more to fight on behalf of his country. This time the mission involves going up against the evil Cunth, who has a nuclear warhead; the mission is personal because Cunth killed MacGruber’s bride. The movie version would see Phillippe playing Piper, an Army officer forced to pair up with a reluctant MacGruber. Kilmer would be Cunth.

I don’t really have a reason for even talking about this, since more than likely, I’ll never even go see it, because the skits aren’t funny and are about fifteen years too late on the reference, but it’s been a slow past month for news and I started writing this up before I realized how much I didn’t feel like writing about this movie, but I got in too deep and decided to finish writing it anyway. So, like, watch this stupid MacGruber skit and then discuss whether The Blues Brothers or Wayne’s World is better, man. ‘Cause I totally can’t decide.

11 response about Has there ever been a good SNL movie? »

  1. MacGruber? Really? Those skits aren’t funny enough to last 60 seconds on the show.

    But I can’t vote on your actual question, because I haven’t seen either The Blues Brothers or Wayne’s World. I saw Superstar, though! For what it’s worth….

    Comment by Jandy Stone — July 8, 2009

  2. at least back at the time i had initially saw it, I liked Coneheads

    Comment by Goon — July 8, 2009

  3. …and I initially at least thought MacGruber was very funny. I dont care if the reference is vastly out of date. if anything, to me thats a plus, because doing parody of things that are too new to me are much more lame.

    I also love Will Forte, he has a hilarious voice, and I actually liked the Brothers Solomon movie because of him.

    So in other words, with Forte and Taccone, I’m willing to give it a chance, but concede it has an uphill battle to be good.

    Comment by Goon — July 8, 2009

  4. I concur, Blues Brothers and Waynes World,

    and OFFICE SPACE is tangentially a SNL movie, considering Mike Judge did the “Milton” animated shorts as SNL Bumpers.

    I didn’t mind Waynes World 2 all that much. But mainly I skip them.

    Anyone see the Stuart Smalley one with Al Franken?

    Comment by Kurt Halfyard — July 8, 2009

  5. When are we going to get HAPPY FUN BALL: THE MOVIE.

    I nominate Larry Cohen to direct.

    Comment by Kurt Halfyard — July 8, 2009

  6. I have a soft spot for The Waterboy.

    Comment by Matt Gamble — July 8, 2009

  7. It’s Pat! Never saw it… otherwise I’d probably be dead.

    Comment by Andrew James — July 8, 2009

  8. Waynes World 2 is better than people remember. its just that like Myers tends to do, he repeated jokes often enough that the other stuff tends to get overshadowed. Love the brief roles from Bob Odenkirk and Robert Smigel as the pathetic nerds at the concert.

    I saw both It’s Pat and Stuart Smalley, i dont remember liking them, but apparently Smalley actually has a cult following, and not for any Franken cult apologetic sake, but because apparently (I was too young to appreciate it on that level to know for sure) it took that character and actually intended to have a somewhat weighty take on family disfunction/alcoholism, etc. – there are quite a few defenders of Stuart Saves His Family out there.

    Comment by Goon — July 8, 2009

  9. http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/19950412/REVIEWS/504120303/1023

    Ebert’s pro-Smalley review

    another tangent:
    A lot of people think SNL movies just dont exist anymore, but its not ENTIRELY true, its just that Lorne Michaels has been producing different stuff. The Ladies Man was an SNL character to film bomb, but after that he instead went behind Mean Girls, Hot Rod, and Baby Mama.

    Most people agree Mean Girls was actually quite good. I actually really like Hot Rod, especially more since its first release now that Danny McBride is more understood/appreciated and the nuances of the Lonely Islands sense of irony is more clear. it’s not perfect but I enjoy it quite a bit. I didnt like Baby Mama at all, but I know a lot of people do, and honestly for a mainstream comedy its at least a step above a lot of stuff.
    The other movies down the pipe from Michaels are starring Fred Willard and Eric Bana, respectively.

    Comment by Goon — July 8, 2009

  10. @Goon, I was vaguely aware of the cult around Smalley – Thanks for the info. I also asked for the sake of all of Franken’s books and political maneuvers lately.

    Comment by Kurt — July 9, 2009

  11. i have some franken stuff

    i have the truncated audio book of “Rush Limbaugh is a big fat idiot” which is mildly funny but dated. His first book is funny and the actual cutting stuff (mostly against Coulter) is completely undeniably true, not arguable. Second book is more of his actual opinions politically and as such not as strong or funny and more quickly dated. His radio show was pretty ass, but I appreciated his true attempts of bringing on dissenting views from big names and giving them respect.

    Ironically politically in book form its weak and the humor shines, but on the show the humor was crap but the political stuff was decent.

    Comment by Goon — July 9, 2009

Leave a comment

Name
Email
Web Site

Recent Comments

Check out our music and literature blog at MorePop.rowthree.com Movie Club Podcast Canadian Cultural Podcasts L.A.M.B.