11 Comments


  1. Goon says:

    Andrew wins the DVD Pick of the Week War

  2. Dave says:

    I’ve been waiting for them to release Budd Boetticher’s Randolph Scott Westerns (most especially TALL T). SEVEN MEN FROM NOW is the only one currently out, and is an excellent movie. Can’t wait to pick up that box set.

    I also remember watching EMMET OTTER’S JUG BAND CHRISTMAS on cable every year around the Holidays. Haven’t seen it in probably 25+ years. It would be interesting to check that out again from a more ‘adult’ perspective. I remember liking it very, very much.

  3. Ross Miller says:

    Good to hear you liked Happy-Go-Lucky, Kurt. I thought it was a great film too, let down only by, as you mentioned in the show, by the unecessary explanation at the end.

    I can’t see why some people are finding Hawkins annoying – she is quite possibly the best character of any film so far this year. But let’s not forget that the movie isn’t just about her, it’s mainly about her affect on other people. She is sort of the example of how happy and upbeat someone can be and by comparison the people around her are shown to be flawed, as everybody is in real life.

    Eddie Marsan is outstanding here, I could watch those driving lesson scenes all day.

    Love that movie.

  4. rot says:

    Entirely agree Ross… it is almost a litmus test for what kind of person you are whether or not Poppy annoys you by her sheer presence. Dostoevsky’s The Idiot plays off a similar conceit, creating a character that is the embodiment of the virtues of Christ, which in a realistic setting would almost inevitably make him a kind of Idiot, a fulfilled naive caring person that the rest of the world berates and plays off of, and Poppy is kind of like that. She is fulfilled, and it is the interaction with the world that makes this a problem, the have nots always ready to knock down the haves, and in this case it is not about class but the commodity of happiness. The ‘drama’ derives solely from this inequality, this inability for the insecure to accept other people being secure, being untethered by the weight of the world.

    I loved Poppy, even when she was jittery and care-free, she has this zen-like quality to her that draws the right people to her, while at the same time confusing and infuriating those not on her wavelength.

    While the perception of this film is that it is drastic change to the Mike Leigh of old, something light and carefree, it is still exactly that universe of naked insecurities, just more often than not it is the secondary characters which possess them.

    What would Naked’s Johnny make of Poppy, eh? There are two forces I would like to see encounter one another.

  5. rot says:

    And I am calling it right here and now: Eddie Marsden will get an Oscar nom, and Sally Hawkins as well.

  6. Ross Miller says:

    Agree totally. A good example is when she’s in the bookshop and the guy behind the counter is obviously in a bad mood and doesn’t like the way Poppy is acting. “Stay happy,” she says.

    And when she goes back to get her bike – ANYONE else would have went crazy if someone had stolen there’s (I’d like to have seen Scott, the driving instructor, in that situation, oh boy:P) but she’s just like, “Oh no…..I didn’t even get to say goodbye.” How fantastic is that! Don’t you wish there were more Poppy’s in the world, if ANY?

  7. Ross Miller says:

    And I’m sorry to say I don’t actually think Marsan will even get a nod never mind an Oscar win which I fully believe he deserves. But I could see them nominating Hawkins, although having said that the Best Actress catagory is always highly competitive – it’s always filled with the most talent imo.

  8. kurt says:

    I’d love to see either of the Happy-Go-Lucky stars get a nod or two. I’ll be watching Hawkins in whatever she does after her tour-de-force in this. I left the theatre in a pretty happy place (despite the blunt closing scene).

  9. Ross Miller says:

    Me too, Kurt. I can’t think of another movie, period, that made me feel as happy as this one did (although Amelie sure comes close). It’s rare for a movie to make you feel something, legitimately feel something, especially nowadays (and particularly in a cinema relased film) and make you carry that feeling after the credits. It happened to me with the phenominal 4 Months, 3 Weeks, 2 Days – after watching that movie I felt like the world was total shit.

  10. Goon says:

    I’ll wait for H-G-L on DVD. The trailer didn’t annoy me. The use of Lily Allen in the trailer seems appropriate, that character seems like one of her songs come to life.

  11. Kurt Halfyard says:

    I can’t say that H-G-L benefits from a big-screen watch. After missing it at TIFF (due to a lost ticket), I simply couldn’t wait to see it as long as Leigh’s films take to get to DVD around here.

    As mentioned just about everywhere, H-G-L will make a great double bill with NAKED, a film I might just pick up on the cheap from Criterion this week.

Leave a comment